Post by account_disabled on Jan 18, 2024 9:38:59 GMT
The Supreme Court has issued ruling 120/2023, of February 2 (Litigation-Administrative Chamber, Section 4) RJ\2023\854, on the exclusion of Bullfighting from the scope of application of the Young Cultural Bonus.
With regard to the legitimation of the appellant foundation , the Supreme Court points out that, in the present case, the argument of the plaintiff foundation was based on the impact on its own interests due to the exclusion of bullfighting shows from among the activities for which it was You can use the Young Cultural Bonus.
Among its statutory purposes[1] the promotion and dissemination of Bullfig Whatsapp Number List hting and the right of everyone to know it, access all its manifestations and exercise them freely are expressly contemplated. Likewise, among its objectives are the preparation of studies, investigations and action plans with measures to promote, protect and disseminate the fighting bull and Bullfighting.
The Supreme Court understands that, although the Toro de Lidia Foundation is not a beneficiary of the Young Cultural Bonus nor does it claim any right when appealing against Royal Decree 210/2022, it does allege its legitimate interest by considering that the exclusion of the cultural bonus effectively harms the promotion of Bullfighting by preventing young people from using the cultural bonus to access bullfighting shows and, to that extent, makes it difficult to achieve its main purpose, if only because said exclusion closes the way for it to be applied. the bonus to those she organizes or helps organize.
For this reason, the Supreme Court declares that in this case there is a sufficient connection between the object of the contentious-administrative appeal and the position of the foundation, and not only because said foundation is a co-organizer of bullfighting shows, nor because it has been considered as interlocutor of the Ministry of Culture and Sports and subsidized by it in particular aspects, but fundamentally for the clear and direct relationship between the purposes it pursues and the result that would be achieved with the estimation of the resource.
With regard to the legitimation of the appellant foundation , the Supreme Court points out that, in the present case, the argument of the plaintiff foundation was based on the impact on its own interests due to the exclusion of bullfighting shows from among the activities for which it was You can use the Young Cultural Bonus.
Among its statutory purposes[1] the promotion and dissemination of Bullfig Whatsapp Number List hting and the right of everyone to know it, access all its manifestations and exercise them freely are expressly contemplated. Likewise, among its objectives are the preparation of studies, investigations and action plans with measures to promote, protect and disseminate the fighting bull and Bullfighting.
The Supreme Court understands that, although the Toro de Lidia Foundation is not a beneficiary of the Young Cultural Bonus nor does it claim any right when appealing against Royal Decree 210/2022, it does allege its legitimate interest by considering that the exclusion of the cultural bonus effectively harms the promotion of Bullfighting by preventing young people from using the cultural bonus to access bullfighting shows and, to that extent, makes it difficult to achieve its main purpose, if only because said exclusion closes the way for it to be applied. the bonus to those she organizes or helps organize.
For this reason, the Supreme Court declares that in this case there is a sufficient connection between the object of the contentious-administrative appeal and the position of the foundation, and not only because said foundation is a co-organizer of bullfighting shows, nor because it has been considered as interlocutor of the Ministry of Culture and Sports and subsidized by it in particular aspects, but fundamentally for the clear and direct relationship between the purposes it pursues and the result that would be achieved with the estimation of the resource.